WildEarth Guardians Sues Colorado over Plan to Kill Black Bears, Mountain Lions - EnviroNews | The Environmental News Specialists

WildEarth Guardians Sues Colorado over Plan to Kill Black Bears, Mountain Lions

(EnviroNews Nature) — Denver, Colorado — The Colorado Parks and Wildlife Department (CPW), the Colorado Parks and Wildlife Commission (Commission) and the Colorado Department of Natural Resources are being sued by WildEarth Guardians (WEG) for their December approval of two predator-killing programs. Through the Piceance Basin Predator Management Plan and Upper Arkansas River Predator Management Plan, CPW aims to kill mountain lions (Puma concolor) and black bears (Ursus americanus) in an attempt to increase mule deer (Odocoileus hemionus) populations. WEG, an environmental nonprofit, says the two initiatives were approved in opposition to Colorado legislation, the science presented to the Commission and extensive public commentary.

The Piceance Basin Predator Management Plan is a three-year strategy to kill between five and 15 mountain lions and 10 to 25 bears annually, “with higher levels possible.” The project will use “cage traps, culvert traps, foot snares, and trailing hounds for capture and a firearm will be used for euthanasia.” The killings are intended for in a 500-square-mile area west of Meeker and Rifle Colorado for which CPW has not provided site-specific bear or mountain lion population estimates.

The Upper Arkansas River Predator Management Plan is a nine-year project, which will use hunting increases to kill substantial percentages of mountain lions in a 2,370-square-mile region in south central Colorado and a neighboring 2,517-square-mile area. Three stages of mountain lion suppression are described within the plan as a “research project,” which aims to “to examine the mule deer population response to cougar suppression.” The stages will involve killing 50 percent of the mountain lions in the first area and 10 percent in the second, then 10 percent in both, then 10 percent in the first and 50 percent in the second. CPW does not have site-specific mountain lion population estimates. If CPW deems it necessary, these hunting initiatives will be followed by trapping and killing by Wildlife Services (WS), the USDA’s highly controversial federal wildlife killing program. In 2016, over 90 percent of respondents to an EnviroNews Poll said Wildlife Services’ killing programs should be abolished.

The Suit States the Killing Plans Are Unconstitutional and Unsupported by Most Coloradans

As WEG points out in a press release, the citizens of Colorado have vocally opposed the recently approved killing tactics and have voted in the past for increased regulation of predator hunting. Bear hunting season in Colorado extends from Sept. 2 to mid-November as defined by a 1992 initiative prohibiting bear hunting from March to Sept. 1. This initiative passed with a 70 percent majority. Amendment 14 to the Colorado Constitution, which passed in 1996, added increased regulations on the permitted methods and purposes of Colorado wildlife trapping and included bans on leghold traps and other body-gripping traps.

The two programs will cost over $4.5 million in Colorado and U.S. funds. Thousands of Coloradans have spoken out against the two strategies and scientists have penned letters explaining they are unnecessary and not founded in science, regarding the species’ population trends, predation history and habitat loss.

The Suit States the Killing Plans are Unscientific

In the press release, Bethany Cotton, WEG Wildlife Program Director, called on CPW to withdraw these initiatives and to “work with leading biologists to understand the existing science on the impacts of predation by carnivores to mule deer, and focus on addressing the main threats to mule deer populations including rampant fossil fuel development and habitat loss.”

The suit states, “CPW’s current goals are based on mule deer inhabiting historical habitat. That habitat includes areas that have been removed and/or degraded by development.” In an email to EnviroNews Nature, WEG Staff Attorney Stuart Wilcox said the habitat destruction arises from many sources and oil and gas development is “a huge driver of habitat loss for the species.”

Wilcox continued in his email to EnviroNews Nature:

Not only can the deer obviously not use well pads, but they also avoid large areas adjacent to well pads due to excessive noise and light concerns… Much of the most problematic habitat loss from a mule deer population-growth perspective is loss of winter range. Much of the oil and gas development in Colorado takes place in basin areas, which are also areas that mule deer prefer to winter in due to milder weather conditions. In fact, the Piceance Basin, where one of these plans is focused, is some of the most critical mule deer habitat in Colorado and the second largest natural gas basin in the entire country. A whole lot of development has already occurred there and the new increased projections of total gas reserves for the Piceance Basin is going to drive increasing development in the area in the future.

Unfortunately, these basin/valley areas are also where people want to build houses to avoid harsher winter conditions, so increasing residential development of these areas is also squeezing the mule deer out of vital habitat. In addition to these sources, there is also competition for available grazing resources from increasing elk populations and from domestic sheep and cattle.

Despite habitat loss, mule deer populations have actually been increasing statewide in recent years and Wilcox said, “if the current trend continues, CPW would meet its mule deer population goals for the state by 2020 without spending over $4.5 million to kill a bunch of mountain lions and bears.” WEG states that CPW reported in 2015 that mule deer populations were increasing in the Piceance Basin and that there had been zero incidents of bear predation and very few involving mountain lions. Wilcox said of these approaches to predator management, “not only are they indefensible from a scientific and policy standpoint on their own, but they don’t even appear to be addressing a need to change management of mule deer to increase populations.”

Black Bear Killed by Hunter

WildEarth Guardians has extensive experience holding governmental agencies accountable for unfounded lethal wildlife management practices and forcing them to stop using unscientific strategies. For example, in October 2016, after years of perseverance, WEG won a landmark settlement that put the brakes on the USDA’s expansive predator killing program Wildlife Services. Federal judges found WS was using outdated and inadequate environmental assessments (EAs) and would have to submit new updated EAs for review in order to continue its wildlife eradications in specific areas. The settlement also resulted in a moratorium on wildlife killing for all practical purposes on public lands in Nevada.

Lauren Truitt, CPW’s Statewide Public Information Officer, told EnviroNews Nature on January 23 that the agency has not yet been served the complaint and is declining to comment until it has reviewed it.

More EnviroNews Stories on WildEarth Guardians’ Lawsuits and Predator-Killing in the West

After a Century, ‘Landmark Settlement’ Puts Brakes on Federal Government’s ‘Rogue’ Wildlife-Killing Program

(EnviroNews Nature) – Missoula, Montana – Well, it only took a century, but it has happened at last: Something finally put the brakes on Wildlife Services (WS), the U.S. Department of Agriculture’s (USDA) “secretive,” “rogue,” “cruel” wildlife-killing agency – and that “something” is the environmental non-profit organization WildEarth…

‘Secret’ Federal Agency Admits Killing 3.2 Million Wild Animals in U.S. Last Year Alone

(EnviroNews DC News Bureau) – Washington D.C. – The United States Department of Agriculture’s (USDA) Wildlife Services (WS) admitted in its annual Program Data Report to having killed at least 3.2 million wild animals in 2015 alone – many of which were large predators. 1,681,283 of that total…

POLL CLOSED: Should USDA’s Secretive Wildlife Killing Program Be Abolished? Yes/No – VIEW RESULTS

(EnviroNews Polls) – 3.2 million animals. That is the amount of critters and creatures brutally eradicated by Wildlife Services (WS) in America last year alone, by way of traps, snares, bullets and poisons – all with your tax dollars of course (at least if you are a U.S….

Five Environmental Groups Sue USDA Over Idaho Wolf-Killing Program

(EnviroNews Idaho) – Boise, Idaho – On June 1, 2016, five prominent environmental organizations filed a lawsuit in federal district court against the United States Department of Agriculture’s (USDA) Wildlife Services for killing over 650 wolves in the state of Idaho over the past decade. Wildlife Services is…

Federal Government Sued For Killing Wolves in Oregon

(EnviroNews Oregon) – Five environmental groups filed a lawsuit on February 3, 2016, in U.S. District Court against the federal agency Wildlife Services, over what they say is the illegitimate killing of wolves in the state of Oregon. WildEarth Guardians, Center for Biological Diversity, Predator Defense, and Project…

Federal Judge Orders Stop to Canadian Lynx Trapping in Idaho

(EnviroNews Idaho) – Boise, Idaho – A federal judge has ordered a stop to the haphazard trapping of Canadian Lynx in Idaho. Lynx canadensis, as it is scientifically known, is one of the rarest cats in the United States and has been captured multiple times in Idaho over…

Feds Attempting to Strip Yellowstone Grizzly Bear of Endangered Species Act Protection

(EnviroNews Wyoming) – Missoula, Montana – In a move that has angered environmentalists and wildlife enthusiasts, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS) proposed on March 3, 2016, to strip the iconic Greater Yellowstone Ecosystem (GYE) grizzly bear of its protected status under the Endangered Species Act (ESA),…

Poll Closed: Should U.S. Government Maintain a Wolf-Killing Program? Yes or No? – View Results

(EnviroNews Polls) – In December of 2015, several environmental groups, spearheaded by WildEarth Guardians, won a pivotal lawsuit against Wildlife Services, a U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) agency, for its wolf-killing program in Washington State. On February 3, 2016, WildEarth Guardians, in concert with four other groups, filed…

No Endangered Species Act Protection for Sonoran Desert Tortoise, Interior Announces

(EnviroNews Arizona) – Washington D.C. – The Morafka’s, or Sonoran desert tortoise, or Gopherus morafkai as it is scientifically known, is a slow moving, yet ancient creature that gets its water from eating native plants while spending most of its time in underground insulated burrows that it digs…

POLL: Should Yellowstone Grizzly Bear Be Delisted, Hunted and Killed? Yes/No? (Feds Say Yes)

(EnviroNews Polls) – On March 3, 2016, the United States Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS) proposed a new rule that would delist the Greater Yellowstone Ecosystem (GYE) grizzly bear, and advocate the hunting and elimination of at least 200 of the region’s approximately 715 specimens. The move fueled…

Will Redrawing Core Sage Grouse Areas in Wyoming Help Save the Bird From Extinction?

(EnviroNews Wyoming) – Douglas, Wyoming – In late April a gloomy report was issued by Pew Charitable Trusts that claims there is a 98.7 percent chance greater sage grouse will go extinct in Wyoming’s Powder River Basin in 30 years if the current course continues. The Powder River…

Dept. of Interior: No Protection for Greater Sage Grouse Under Endangered Species Act

(EnviroNews DC News Bureau) – Commerce City, Colorado – On the morning of Tuesday August 22, 2015, Department of the Interior (DOI) Secretary Sally Jewell announced that Centrocercus urophasianus, a.k.a. greater sage grouse, will not receive protection under the Endangered Species Act (ESA). A decision by U.S. Fish…

WA State Stops Bloodshed After Massacring Profanity Peak Wolf Pack To Appease Cattle Ranchers

(EnviroNews Washington) – Olympia, Washington – The Washington Department of Fish and Wildlife (WDFW) announced October 19, 2016, that it would spare the remaining four members of the now demolished Profanity Peak Wolf Pack, after already having killed seven of its wolves (Canis lupus) to appease cattle ranchers….

WildEarth Guardians: DOI’s Bi-State Sage Grouse ‘Conservation Success’ Is ‘Window Dressing’

(EnviroNews Wyoming) – Douglas, Wyoming – On April 21, 2015 Secretary of the Department of the Interior (DOI) Sally Jewell appeared in Reno, Nevada to make a pivotal Bi-State Sage Grouse Announcement: No protection under the Endangered Species Act (ESA) for the bi-state distinct population of the greater…

Jeremy Nichols of WildEarth Guardians Discusses the Joint Lawsuit Against Rio Tinto-Kennecott

(EnviroNews Utah) – Salt Lake City – Today, Jeremy Nichols, Climate and Energy Program Director for WildEarth Guardians, alongside of the Utah Physicians For a Healthy Environment and the Utah Mom’s For Clean Air, announced the filing of a joint lawsuit against Kennecott Utah Copper. The suit claims…

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

, , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,